Professionals register now to create your own content and profile, and gain other potential financial, networking and marketing benefits.
Consumers (athletes, enthusiasts) use our quick registration to enhance your experience of the site
Keegan: A(nother) Case of Hearts over Heads in the Toon?
When Sam Allardyce left Newcastle United last week after less than a
year, it became clear that cold, hard analysis wasn't behind the
decision. All of the respected commentators agreed that Big Sam needed
time, and that given time he would develop a strong team.
But that wasn't the issue, was it? As Alan Green summed up perfectly while commenting on the Man United vs Newcastle match last weekend, Allardyce's failure was not on the field, even though results were unspectacular. He was never the right man for Newcastle. In a city where passions run high, he was never able to make the emotional connection with the Toon Army that Kevin Keegan did. Maybe it was the style of football. Maybe it was his personal style. Maybe both.
Kevin Keegan hasn't been in football for a few years. There's nothing rational that suggests he's really the man for the job (whatever the job actually is) - although he might do well - but he's a hero on Tyneside and has already captured the hearts of the fans. That might be all that the manager needs up there. Certainly any manager needs the good will of the fans at some time or another.
For Big Sam, there is the comfort of a huge payoff, but his pride will be dented. If nothing else, he will hopefully have learned a big lesson in stakeholder management.
What price for Shearer as assistant? (He was pretty cagey on Match of the Day tonight).
Is Keegan the right choice? Discuss the appointment here.
But that wasn't the issue, was it? As Alan Green summed up perfectly while commenting on the Man United vs Newcastle match last weekend, Allardyce's failure was not on the field, even though results were unspectacular. He was never the right man for Newcastle. In a city where passions run high, he was never able to make the emotional connection with the Toon Army that Kevin Keegan did. Maybe it was the style of football. Maybe it was his personal style. Maybe both.
Kevin Keegan hasn't been in football for a few years. There's nothing rational that suggests he's really the man for the job (whatever the job actually is) - although he might do well - but he's a hero on Tyneside and has already captured the hearts of the fans. That might be all that the manager needs up there. Certainly any manager needs the good will of the fans at some time or another.
For Big Sam, there is the comfort of a huge payoff, but his pride will be dented. If nothing else, he will hopefully have learned a big lesson in stakeholder management.
What price for Shearer as assistant? (He was pretty cagey on Match of the Day tonight).
Is Keegan the right choice? Discuss the appointment here.
Rob Robson
Sport and Business Psychologist, WarwickshireTags:
emotion,
football,
kevin keegan,
management,
messiah,
newscastle,
stakeholder management,
toon army
Posted January 16, 2008 at 2:33 PM by robrobson
in
Football Psychology, Leadership & Management in Sport | Permalink | Comments(3)
Post A Comment
You need to be signed into istadia.com to post comments
If you are not a member yet, registering is quick and easy! Click here for Quick Registration and keep up to date with what is happening, engage in some networking and access to iStadia’s expert community.
However if you are a sport & exercise professional or business and would like to promote yourself by building a detailed, search-engine friendly profile and posting content to attract potential clients, customers or employers, we recommend Full Registration.
Comments
Rob Robson
Sport and Business Psychologist, Warwickshire