The Use of Social Networking within the Sport and Exercise Sciences

Category: Sports Business | Specialism: Sports Marketing
Views: 1551 | 5 people like this | Print | Share | Flag
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

The purpose of this article is to discuss social networking as a creative industry

This article has been reproduced by the kind permisson of the London Journal of Tourism, Sport and Creative Industries 
Link: http://www.emklondon.com

The Use of Social Networking within the Sport and Exercise Sciences

James T. Beale
Department of Health and Biosciences
University Of East London

The idea of social networking has gained a mass of attention in recent years.  This has come about from both a social and a business perspective and is evident through the popularity of websites such as Facebook, MySpace, LinkedIn and Bebo to name but a few.  The scale of social networking can be seen by its usage with Facebook having over 80 million members worldwide.  More recently there has been the introduction of industry specific social networking sites.  This article will review social networking from this perspective and will discuss the usage of social networking within the sport and exercise area.

Social networking is the commonly accepted term and is something that encompasses those looking to grow networks in both social and business settings.  The purpose of this article is to discuss social networking as a creative industry. As such at this stage of the article, it is useful to replace the term social networking to either contact networking or business networking as suggested by Keith Irving (2007), one of the co-founders of iStadia, the sport and exercise social networking website.

History has demonstrated that new technological advances have made a huge difference to our lives and to the sport and exercise sciences.  It was only 10 years ago that as a student my lectures were often delivered with the aide of an overhead projector.  Now, having worked as an academic for the past 6 years it would be laughable to turn up to present a lecture without a polished power point presentation.  Within the sport and exercise domain it was standard practice to use a hand held stopwatch to measure sprint tests in the not too distant past.  However, now with the introduction of specialist wing gates, when the athlete breaks a laser beam they start the timing of a sprint and we can take several split times throughout a 12 second sprint, giving us additional information on separate segments of the sprint that is far more accurate than using hand held stop watches.  Both of the technological advancements mentioned above provide us with an alternative and an improved way of looking at the already existing issues (in this case presentation aids and time measuring equipment). 

As with the above issues the idea of networking is far from new, the phrase ‘old school tie’ has connotations of jobs being given out as a result of the school that you attended and by implications through the network of people that were around the individual at a very young age.  With the above issues of technological advancement and the networking process it is deemed worthy to consider new advancements in the form of internet based social networking within specialist industries.  Broadly, social networking works on the premise that in order to get to a specific destination (be that from a social, romantic or a business perspective) people considerably raise their chances through knowing people who know people who in turn know other people.  Through knowing the first person you raise your chances of getting to know the important person in that chain. The most basic explanation that may help is to look at it in the same way as we use a map to get to a destination.  To get to a specific destination it is necessary to know what route to take and it is helpful to have another alternative route just in case something unexpected happens on that specific route.  Similarly if we are looking to get to a specific point for example a job or a ‘in the door’ of a big client.  The route to get to a desired destination is often clear in terms of the qualifications necessary for a specific job.  However it not so clear as to why people with the same qualifications differ in terms of their success. One possible reason for this brings to mind the old adage of ‘it is not what you know but who you know’ that is the reason for occupational success.  Through a utilising a process of networking we may well enhance our chances of getting to know the correct people.  Internet based social networking in this case can allow us to be strategic and get to know the right person through going through a series of steps to get to the person that we need to know in order to enhance our chance of getting that desired job in the same way that a map can assist us with getting to a physical destination.

At present the niche market of sport and exercise social networking is exclusively carried out through iStadia.  The website was initially set up in March 2007 and in the period March 2007 to March 2008 has accrued approximately 500 members.  Personally as a member since May 2007 I consider the site has generally developed in a way to assist its members.  As a social networking site it provides the following opportunities.

The first opportunity is about marketing yourself and your skills.  You are given a series of pages and an opportunity to advertise yourself and the skills that you have.  Through these pages there is also a free advert where you can direct visitors to your personal website or your employer’s website.  The format of the website is very clear and it allows members without a current internet presence to gain access to this medium in a very clear and professional manner.  The next stage is that similarly to other ‘web 2.0 sites’ like YouTube you are able to add user-generated content for public viewing.  This is done in the forms of blogs and articles.  Once this is done members have the opportunity to rate and comment on the blog or article.  Irving (2007) points out in his article explaining the benefits of adding information to a networking site.

“Articles can be added and discussed and then rated.  In the not too distant future we will add wiki’s which will allow knowledge/research to be added by members (as in wikipedia).  This means that it will also be right up to date  and not one or two years behind when it eventually appears in a journal” (Irving, 2007).

Once joined you then have the option to contact others and others can contact you to join in each of their networks.  This acts as a kind of introduction which is personalised through a message of invitation, once formed this acts as a form of non committal partnership.  On first usage I found this to be slightly uncomfortable.  However there have been a number of times over the past year when I have utilised these contacts and that people have come to me for among other things referrals, a very welcome thing.  There have also been a number of less welcomed approaches for advice on things such as training to become a sport psychologist.  Despite the latter being described as ‘less welcomed’ it was still nice to have the contact with people that once would hope would take the advice well and perhaps spring up again in other capacities in future.  There have also been a number of people who have contacted me to join their network that I have not heard from since agreeing.

The site has also come in useful in terms of providing a forum on which to have a transparent communication process for a group that I run independently of the site in the form of a private club.  This has enabled group members to continue discussions after our seminars have finished in a way that, everyone can see through follow up on topics and by making arrangements for other events.  This has been a very positive experience for all those involved in the group.

The site also provides public clubs where all members can join to discuss topics such as motivation for sport or strength and conditioning.  There are a number of these public clubs where information and opinion can be passed and discussed on a range of topics.  These clubs appear to be set to grow and I would suggest provide a useful forum for areas such as peer consultation.

The final part of this site is centred around continued professional development (CPD) courses.  This particular area appears somewhat unique to this form of medium.  However from a users perspective it is refreshing to see a group put on high quality CPD courses outside of the governing body attempts.  The jury is still very much out on the quality of these courses.  However the potential is there for this to bring a new perspective on CPD with the sport and exercise sciences.

Having made a strong case for the usage of social networking within the sport and exercise sciences and the current medium for doing so there is a concern that I have about the efficacy of the social networking in the manner mentioned above.  I would hope that these would form the basis of discussion questions.  The concern is based purely on my opinion and anecdotal experience of using the site over the past year.

The issue is to do with quality control.  To take as a first point the issue of articles and blogs. It is true that the articles can be reviewed by what is in some cases represents a peer group.  Each member of iStadia has the opportunity to comment on articles downloaded.  However there is nothing to stop articles being published that have opinions within them that are ill informed and go against any previous research indicators.  This is something which the academic community may find especially difficult as it would be an easy mistake for a student to make, referencing what they consider to be an academically rigorous resource which could actually have been written by any member or any academic with an axe to grind without sufficient evidence to make assertions. To add to this the issue of publishing data there is also the issue of no restrictions on members.  On day one of my Masters degree I distinctly remember the tutor saying ‘beware of cowboys spurs clanging.  The industry is fraught with cowboys who have done a 2 week course and then decided to call themselves a sport psychologist’.  These are words that stay with me to this day.  This site appears to do nothing to stop these issues and there are a number of people promoting themselves as what appears to go way beyond that of what their qualifications seem to suggest. 

Industry indications would appear to suggest that there will be a lowering of usage of more mainstream sites such as Facebook.  However industry indications would appear to suggest that there will be a role for this form of medium in future.  With this in mind it makes the idea more appealing, and a way to do business and form business connections which may well be here for sometime to come.

In summary, as a user of the site I have had a very positive experience of using the iStadia website and would suggest that web based social networking has a place in future and is something that is worthy of consideration for those involved in most niche markets.  I consider the pros of this medium to far outweigh the cons and that those areas of concern represent challenges that can be overcome by the industry and it is my anticipation that this will happen in the future.

References:
Irving, K. (2007). Social networking: Why it's special and why it should be of interest to you. Retrieved 8th February, 2008, from www.istadia.com/article/keithirving/13


About the author:
James Beale is a Senior Lecturer in Sport and Exercise Psychology at the University of East London where he has worked since 2002.  James is also a chartered psychologist that regularly works supporting athletes within a range of different sports as a practicing sport psychologist. 


About the Journal
London is one of the world’s most heterogeneous and cosmopolitan cities. It is a quintessential ‘global city' located at the interface of manifold networks, flows and motilities. The London Journal of Tourism, Sport and Creative Industries (LJTSCI) seeks to publish articles on a variety of related topics which encapsulates this diversity and the nature of its local-global intersections.
The subject area delivered at London Metropolitan University has a history of high quality research into
anthropological/developmental studies and policy analysis. It is from these platforms that the journal aims to be a meeting place for research and discussion on a wealth of topics that should appeal to scholars,
practitioners, policy makers and general readers. These articles can include research, works-in progress, case studies, developments in theory, book reviews and general reviews that contributes to the development of the subject field.
The journal addresses a broad subject field, while under the banner of Tourism, Sport and the Creative
Industries it also includes, but is not restricted to, events, the Arts – including music and dance, heritage,
hospitality, advertising & communications, music media & entertainment. We encourage submissions relating to these topics from a wide variety of perspectives; such as all areas of anthropology, management, economics, politics, history, sociology, psychology, cultural studies and marketing. The contexts of these research papers are also broad in scope covering relevant research from public, commercial and third sector
organisations and settings.
Editorial Board
Julie Scott, Tom Selwyn, I-Ling Kuo, Nicole Ferdinand, Milan Todorovic, Ioannis Pantelidis, Paul Kitchin, Ruth Marciniak, Ezendu Ariwa
 

Keith
Keith Irving
iStadia

Comments

I wrote this article about a year ago. It is worth considering that the information on Istadia membership is hugely different now.

Perhaps Keith or Rob you could provide the current data to show how the membership has risen so quickly over that period which surely adds to the benefits of the module.

I would have further added that I got additional business through the website in the summer. I have also began to use the site when training sport psychologists and taking them through the BASES supervised experience process. For further information on that course please see the link below:
http://www.totalperformance.co.uk/training.html

Well done for putting this up so quickly Keith, it was only published last week!

James Beale

James Beale C.Psychol

Director Of Total Performance Consulting Limited
07985414942

"Realise and fulfill your potential"

www.totalperformance.co.uk<
Thanks for that James; valuable input and feedback on iStadia is always welcome. We now have over 800 members and hit over 35000 pageviews per month.

It's also very satisfying to hear that members are continuing to get business from their links on iStadia.

You made some insightful comments about quality which we would like to take further regarding the way in which articles could be reviewed (peer reviewed or otherwise) and I would certainly like to hear from others and you yourself James about how we could improve this.

Keith
Keith Irving
iStadia
Thanks James


I'm interested in the quality issue. On one hand, iStadia creates a very democratic form of knowledge sharing. Peer reviewed journals have stringent standards, but are inaccessible to most, either through availability or language. Articles are not written to be accessed by the lay performer or coach. If we all act as reviewers, and challenge unsupported or unacceptable statements, then even 'poor' quality articles can add value and open debate.


This does not mean, however, that we should not be open to some form of quality control - but who would be the judge and arbitrer?


Cheers


Rob

--
Rob Robson
Co-founder, iStadia.com
I think quality control on an "open" site is always going to be an issue, but do you really want to restrict opinion just because it doesn't adhere to journal standards? I agree it would be better to challenge facts presented in an article or blog, but without turning it into too much of a critical analysis, which I fear would deter members from posting, and possibly put off new members.

As to the usefulness of networking, business networking has long held the view that "Givers Gain" i.e. look for opportunities to help others rather than just helping yourself. I would suggest the same applies on iStadia.

Gary Baker
The Centre for Sports Hypnosis
Regarding the quality issue. I appreciate what Rob is saying. However I personally find it difficult to say to someone that there article is in some way inappropriate. Being critical in this way will not help with the way that people view the person criticising.

I have seen several articles on here that I think are not of a very high quality and are based on opinion. I have also seen articles from this website referenced in students work which I do not think is necessarily appropriate. There was an article not so long ago on Rugby and how England would win the Rugby World Cup. We obviously did not but the ideas were based on the writers desire for this to happen rather than the any real scientific opinion. When these opinions are presented as fact subsequently this leads to confusion.

In terms of who judges. Well I don't know. Perhaps members could come up with ideas?

I have also seen a lot of good articles written on Istadia especially the one above !). In all seriousness I have generally had a very positive experience of using Istadia and do not wish to come across as negative.

JB




James Beale C.Psychol

Director Of Total Performance Consulting Limited
07985414942

"Realise and fulfill your potential"

www.totalperformance.co.uk<
James, if your article was not balanced it would lack credibility, so don't pull punches. On criticism, it doesn't have to be about point scoring, or putting down the author or article. But feedback can help the author, or a question can open up debate. There may be an angle, theory, or piece of evidence that the author is not aware of. In this respect, writing and responding to articles becomes a collaborative venture. If an author doesn't want to receive comments, they can switch them off!

--
Rob Robson
Co-founder, iStadia.com
Sorry for over-commenting but I also wanted to comment on students referencing articles on here. I noticed a few years back when lecturing that students were not as critical in their analysis of evidence as I would have expected. You know what, if students can't discern between a well-written and evidenced piece of writing and an opinion piece then shame on them. Likewise, if a University is not teaching students to critically analyse their sources, the shame on them too!

--
Rob Robson
Co-founder, iStadia.com
Sure, but there is confusion when a website like istadia with high profile members make comments based on opinions then I think it is reasonable for students to get confused. I am very positive about the site but as with anything there are pros and cons.

It is interesting that we are not debating the pros!

Re the idea of offering an alternative view. I see your point and it would not hurt to do it. I suppose it is partly due to time and partly due to not wanting to offend anyone. One point I would make is that there is not enough of it right now. Maybe this is a way for Istadia to develop?

James Beale C.Psychol

Director Of Total Performance Consulting Limited
07985414942

"Realise and fulfill your potential"

www.totalperformance.co.uk<
Of course iStadia is fantastic in many ways!

--
Rob Robson
Co-founder, iStadia.com

As a relative newcomer to iStadia but as a long term user and contributer to social media sites online, I think the issues we are discussing here are exactly the same as those faced by countless other so called Web 2.0 sites.



Think Wikipedia as one example where the bar for publishing anything is set very low but the stringency of having it stay published is very high. I think that works up to a point but I'm not sure it's the best thing for iStadia to aspire to.



There are plenty of peer reviewed sources where people can send letters, articles, papers or whatever. If a site like iStadia were to go down that road then two problems emerge immediately. Firstly, who would have the time to do the vetting of articles or blog posts and what standard would they apply? Secondly, if it's left for the community to edit in a wiki style format then the original views of any writer quickly get lost. A camel is a horse that was designed by a committee ... and the same can be said for many wiki creations.

My vote would be to allow open posting of articles but for all articles to allow comments. Then discussion is generated and it both can and should be as robust as the commenter feels necessary. Search engines love the changing content and more users get drawn to the site by finding iStadia pages showing up well in search engine results.



One feature that iStadia might explore however ... if we want to go part way down this route ... is to start a true "WIKI" section of the site. This would allow commenting and editing and a more reference based information resource.



Doctor Gordon Cameron
Sports and Orthopaedic Physician
Special interest in shoulder pain problems
 
This was written a long time ago. Would it be useful to get another one out there with an honest appraisal of how things have developed. Perhaps this time it could be a joint effort?

I know that the LJTSCI would accept it however I was wondering about getting something into a more specific journal.

I could help in the following ways:
a. Get a student to do this as part of their dissertation (this would mean that we could not think about publication for sometime to come though, probably sending it in June 2010)
b. I would be happy to put this through the UEL ethics committee
c. Take my share of the load in terms of writing this up and interviewing people if this was the design that we decided to take.

Right! Anyone interested?

I think we need:
1. People that run Istadia
2. Statistics on usage (not biased!)
3. Active members (perhaps 3)
4. Non active members (again perhaps )


In terms of research we need someone to do a literature search on social networking and its benefits

Agreement on design (my vote would be some form of qualitative analysis, however I am open to some form of quantitative analysis especially if someone has the skill set to be able to able to analyse the info)

That would appear to be enough to be getting on with.




James Beale C.Psychol
07985414942

Total Performance Consulting - Sport Psychologists
That would be really interesting. We can provide open access to stats for analysis, as much as Google analytics will provide, and to the stats and demographics that our database would provide.


An interesting question would be whether sport and exercise professionals are as active networking online or using social media as other professional groups. My suspicion is that we are 'behind the curve' a bit. Clearly as we don't have other professional groups on here you couldn't fully answer that question, but you could go some of the way....

--
Rob Robson
Co-founder, iStadia.com
Rob Robson on Twitter

Post a Comment

Html formatting: <br /> (line break) <p></p> (paragraph) <b></b> (bold) <i></i> (italics)

You need to be signed into istadia.com to post comments

If you are not a member yet, registering is quick and easy! Sign up Now to keep up-to-date, network or promote yourself; or read more about the benefits.

Members login here.

Raise your game. Sign up now!
Read more first





Keith Irving's Articles

March 2010
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031 

Search Keith's Article


Online UK Job Search | CV Preview
Clicky Web Analytics